Nia Vardalos

Genevieve Gernier

John Corbett

Greg Gatlin

Jason Mantzoukas

Brian Blowdell

Judah Friedlander

Dan O'Finn

Zoe Kazan

Tammy Greenwood

Stephen Guarino

Bill

Amir Arison

Bob

Gary Wilmes

Cal

Mike Starr

John

Rachel Dratch

Kathy Jeemy

Jay O. Sanders

Tim the Delivery Guy

Suzanne Shepherd

Edie

Ben Schwartz

Tammy's Date

Dan Finnerty

Grouchy Guy

Lynda Gravatt

Rose

John Tormey

Moe

Ward Horton

Mark

Isiah Whitlock Jr.

Drummer

Ian Gomez

KJ Ken

Rose Abdoo

Attractive Woman

Howard Feller

Homeless Guy

Autumn Ready Potter

Barbie

Tracy Thorpe

Giddy Woman

Kapil Bawa

Nerdy Man

Wali Collins

Desperate Customer

Miriam Tolan

Artsy Woman

Rachel Hamilton

Woman in Gallery

David Beach

Husband in Gallery

Gaetano Iacono

Big Worker

Cher Cosenza

Jill (uncredited)

Brett Berg

Punky (uncredited)

Ronnie Kroell

Tapas Server (uncredited)

Peter Conboy

Neighborhood Guy (uncredited)